James McAtee
Nottingham Forest · CM
He fits best in high-intensity pressing football and is best suited to the role of box-to-box midfielder.
Medium confidence: a fair amount of playing time and evidence. 839 minutes counted.
How he plays
Main style: Ball winner. Wins the ball back and disrupts opponents.
Also: Runner.
Strongest areas: match load (93/100), winning the ball (73/100).
- • Influence on games is a weak point (26/100). How much he affects what happens in a match.
- • Discipline is a weak point (25/100). Staying out of bookings.
Best styles of team for him
Marked out of 100. 90+ excellent, 80 to 89 strong, 70 to 79 conditional, 60 to 69 limited, below 60 poor.
- 61
High-intensity pressing football
Wins the ball high up the pitch with a coordinated, tireless press.
Often seen as: 4-3-3, 4-2-3-1, Aggressive 3-4-3
Limited fit
Suits the role62With the ball45Without the ball69Switching between the two73Physical load93Flexibility30Why it works: winning the ball, match load.
What could go wrong: discipline is a weak point and this style leans on it.
Evidence behind this score: 70%
- 56
Structured positional attacking
Rotates players between positions so the shape changes as the team attacks.
Often seen as: 4-3-3 turning into 3-2-5, 4-2-3-1 turning into 2-3-5
Poor fit
Suits the role62With the ball53Without the ball45Switching between the two73Physical load61Flexibility30Why it works: match load, winning the ball.
What could go wrong: discipline is a weak point and this style leans on it.
Evidence behind this score: 70%
- 55
Transition-based football
Attacks quickly the moment the ball is won, using space left behind.
Often seen as: Direct 4-4-2, Transitional 4-3-3, 5-3-2
Poor fit
Suits the role62With the ball46Without the ball43Physical load93Flexibility30Why it works: match load, winning the ball.
What could go wrong: discipline is a weak point and this style leans on it.
Evidence behind this score: 60%
- 53
Positional possession football
Controls games by keeping the ball and moving it patiently through set positions.
Often seen as: 4-3-3, 3-2-5 in possession, 2-3-5 in possession
Poor fit
Suits the role62Without the ball49Physical load53Flexibility30Why it works: match load, winning the ball.
What could go wrong: discipline is a weak point and this style leans on it.
Evidence behind this score: 50%
- 47
Compact defensive and counter-attacking football
Stays tight and organised, then hits the opponent on the break.
Often seen as: 4-4-2, 5-3-2, 5-4-1
Poor fit
Suits the role62With the ball37Without the ball53Switching between the two37Physical load53Flexibility30Why it works: match load, winning the ball.
What could go wrong: discipline is a weak point and this style leans on it.
Evidence behind this score: 60%
Best roles for him
Roles in the position he plays now. “Demonstrated” means he has played enough to prove it; “Indicative” means an early sign.
- 62
Box-to-box midfielder
Covers huge ground, wins the ball and gets into the box.
IndicativeLimited fitStrong at: match load, winning the ball
Not judged yet: moving the ball forward
- 41
Advanced playmaker
Creates chances from central areas with incisive passing.
IndicativePoor fitWeak at: influence on games
Not judged yet: passing quality, moving the ball forward, decision-making
- –
Controller
Sets the tempo and keeps the ball moving safely.
Not enough evidenceWeak at: influence on games
Not judged yet: passing quality, staying calm under pressure, reading space, decision-making
Could he play somewhere else?
No clear positional experiment from the evidence we have.
Weak points to watch
- • Influence on games is a weak point (26/100). How much he affects what happens in a match.
- • Discipline is a weak point (25/100). Staying out of bookings.
- • Positional possession football asks a lot of discipline, which is a weak point for him.
- • High-intensity pressing football asks a lot of discipline, which is a weak point for him.
- • Transition-based football asks a lot of discipline, which is a weak point for him.
- • Structured positional attacking asks a lot of discipline, which is a weak point for him.
What we still need to know
- • Moving the ball forward: Passes and carries that break lines.
Missing evidence is never counted as a weakness. These need scouting or detailed match-event data.
Every quality we looked at
- Creating chances53
Setting up shots and goals for team-mates.
- Goal threat41
Getting into scoring positions and finishing.
- Winning the ball73
Tackles, recoveries and blocks that stop attacks.
- Keeping goals outnot enough playing time
How well his team protects its goal when he plays.
- Influence on games26
How much he affects what happens in a match.
- Match load93
How many minutes he can play and keep playing.
- Discipline25
Staying out of bookings.
- Passing qualityneeds scouting
Accuracy and range of passing.
- Moving the ball forwardneeds scouting
Passes and carries that break lines.
- Staying calm under pressureneeds scouting
Keeping the ball when opponents close him down.
- Reading spaceneeds scouting
Finding and using gaps, and covering them.
- Speedneeds scouting
Acceleration and top speed.
- Aerial abilityneeds scouting
Winning headers in both boxes.
- Decision-makingneeds scouting
Choosing the right action quickly.
Each mark is out of 100 against other players in his position, 50 is typical. Marks tagged “scout rating” come from a scout's written assessment, the rest from match stats.
Tactical fit is not the same as how good a player is or how good he could become. A fit score is a guide based on the stats we hold, not a guarantee of success, and the bands are starting values we will adjust against real results. Anything we cannot measure yet is left out, never counted as a weakness. Model tactical-v1.
