Regret index
How likely each signing is to be seen later as a mistake, out of 100. Higher means more regret. It looks at how far he is below the club's target, whether better options were missed, how well he fits, how big the bet was and whether the problem keeps showing. Tap a player to see the stats behind his score.
How many signings in each group
- 1Maxence LacroixVFLVfL Wolfsburg→
CRYHigh regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample65regret - 2Elliot Anderson
NEW→
NFOModerate regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample58regret - 3Jaden Philogene
HUL→
AVLModerate regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample58regret - 4Ross BarkleyLUTLuton Town→
AVLModerate regretPlayed 43% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample50regret - 5Iliman NdiayeMARMarseille→
EVEModerate regretPlayed 20% of possible minutes in 2 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample48regret - 6Eddie Nketiah
ARS→
CRYModerate regretPlayed 32% of possible minutes in 9 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample47regret - 7Mikel MerinoREAReal Sociedad→
ARSModerate regretPlayed 22% of possible minutes in 9 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample45regret - 8Jack Clarke
SUN→
IPSModerate regretPlayed 32% of possible minutes in 8 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample45regret - 9Joachim Andersen
CRY→
FULModerate regretPlayed 21% of possible minutes in 3 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample44regret - 10Noussair MazraouiBAYBayern Munich→
MANModerate regretPlayed 26% of possible minutes in 4 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample43regret - 11Mats WiefferPSVPSV Eindhoven→
BHALimited regretPlayed 25% of possible minutes in 4 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample39regret - 12Dominic Solanke
BOU→
TOTLimited regretPlayed 54% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample37regret - 13Jacob Greaves
HUL→
IPSLimited regretPlayed 50% of possible minutes in 5 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample36regret - 14William OsulaSHESheffield United→
NEWLimited regretPlayed 39% of possible minutes in 6 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample36regret - 15Sepp van den Berg
LIV→
BRELimited regretPlayed 36% of possible minutes in 4 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample29regret - 16SávioUnknown→
MNCLimited regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample27regret - 17Liam Delap
MNC→
IPSLimited regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample26regret - 18Sander BergeBURBurnley→
FULLimited regretPlayed 82% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence26regret - 19Dara O'SheaBURBurnley→
IPSLimited regretPlayed 100% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence22regret - 20Nikola MilenkovicFIOFiorentina→
NFOLow regretPlayed 60% of possible minutes in 6 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample19regret - 21Kiernan Dewsbury-HallLEILeicester City→
CHELow regretPlayed 0% of possible minutes in 0 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample18regret - 22Leny YoroLILLille→
MANLow regretPlayed 49% of possible minutes in 7 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample8regret - 23Mike PendersRACRacing Genk→
CHELow regretPlayed 32% of possible minutes in 4 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample8regret - 24David Raya
BRE→
ARSLow regretPlayed 100% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence2regret - 25Ferdi KadiogluFENFenerbahce→
BHALow regretPlayed 58% of possible minutes in 7 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · early read: small sample0regret - 26EvanilsonFC FC Porto→
BOULow regretPlayed 94% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 27Pedro NetoWOLWolverhampton Wanderers→
CHELow regretPlayed 83% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 28Riccardo CalafioriBOLBologna→
ARSLow regretPlayed 86% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 29Malick YalcouyéIFKIFK Göteborg→
BHALow regretPlayed 36% of possible minutes in 9 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · early read: small sample0regret - 30Archie Gray
LEE→
TOTLow regretPlayed 79% of possible minutes in 9 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 31Igor ThiagoCLUClub Brugge→
BRELow regretPlayed 92% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 32Lewis Hall
CHE→
NEWLow regretPlayed 100% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a development prospect (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret - 33Daichi KamadaLAZLazio→
CRYLow regretPlayed 98% of possible minutes in 10 gamesSigned as a regular rotation (assumed) · fair amount of evidence0regret
The number on the left is the rank: 1 is the most regretted. Circle colour compares the signings on this list, red for the most regret and green for the least. The words under each name give the absolute level.
25 signings are not scored yet. Missing evidence is left out, never counted as zero.
Sporting delivery measured against the role a signing was meant to fill. Fees are not used, so this is not a financial ROI. The Regret Index is an evidence-based signal, not a verdict on a club's decision. Weights and thresholds are starting hypotheses.





























